TELECOM Digest OnLine - Sorted: Google Stashes Away $200 Million For Lawsuits With YouTube

Google Stashes Away $200 Million For Lawsuits With YouTube

Jonathan Thaw (
Sat, 18 Nov 2006 23:08:41 -0600

By Jonathan Thaw

Nov. 15 (Bloomberg) -- Google Inc.'s decision to establish a reserve
of more than $200 million for possible lawsuits against YouTube
underscores the company's concern over the use of copyrighted clips at
the video-sharing Web site.

Google, the most-used Internet search engine, said yesterday it set
aside 12.5 percent of the shares issued to buy YouTube for one year to
"secure certain indemnification obligations."

The company is trying to protect itself against lawsuits over
copyrighted material on YouTube, a Web site where people watch
everything from fountains made with Diet Coke and Mentos to dancing
men on treadmills. YouTube is removing clips of shows including NBC
Universal's "The Office" and creating software that lets media
companies pull unauthorized videos or share in advertising sales.

"It's inevitable that they'll be making use of copyrighted material,"
said Lee Bromberg, an intellectual property attorney at Boston-based law
firm Bromberg & Sunstein. It's 'awfully hard' to get permission from
everyone whose content may appear on the site, he said.

Chief Executive Officer Eric Schmidt said last week Google 'has talked
to everybody' about licensing video. His remarks came a day before
Mountain View, California-based Google said in its quarterly report that
'substantial harm' may result from copyright lawsuits.

Shares of Google rose $8.27 to $489.30 yesterday in Nasdaq Stock Market
composite trading and are up 18 percent this year.

YouTube's Policy

YouTube officials weren't available to comment, the company's outside
public relations firm said. Google spokesmen Gabriel Stricker and
Ricardo Reyes didn't respond to phone calls or e-mails seeking comment.

YouTube says it removes material from the site when copyright owners
protest. It would be impossible to screen each of the 65,000 clips
added each day, and the law is designed to protect the company from
having to do that, spokeswoman Julie Supan said in a Nov. 6 interview.

Unauthorized clips are being scrubbed from YouTube. A search this month
for NBC's 'The Office,' a spoof documentary about a paper supplier in
Scranton, Pennsylvania, produced a message that said, "This video has
been removed at the request of copyright owner NBC Universal because its
content was used without permission."

The clips, posted by users, were removed even as NBC and YouTube work
together. YouTube agreed in June to promote NBC's fall television
lineup and create an official NBC channel on the site. NBC, a unit of
Fairfield, Connecticut-based General Electric Co., agreed to promote
YouTube on the air. Kathy Kelly-Brown, a spokeswoman for NBC
Universal, didn't have a comment on the network's relationship with

Music Videos

YouTube is also brokering other deals. The San Bruno, California-based
company signed licensing agreements with music companies including
Warner Music Group, Universal Music Group and Sony BMG Music
Entertainment in the past two months.

YouTube also is showing news, sports and entertainment clips from CBS
Corp., owner of the most-watched U.S. television network. New
York-based CBS is the first TV network to test YouTube software that
identifies copyrighted clips on the site. CBS can then decide whether
to take down the content or leave it and share advertising revenue.

YouTube will need more of those agreements to preserve the site's
diversity, a feature that spurred its popularity.

"You could go there and be fairly confident you could find anything,"
said Greg Sterling, an analyst at Sterling Market Intelligence in
Oakland, California. If users find too many error messages or too much
that has been taken off the site, that could create a 'real vulner-
ability,' he said.

To contact the reporter on this story: Jonathan Thaw in San Francisco at .

NOTE: For more telecom/internet/networking/computer news from the
daily media, check out our feature 'Telecom Digest Extra' each day at . Hundreds of new
articles daily. And, discuss this and other topics in our forum at (or)

For more news and headlines, please go to:

Post Followup Article Use your browser's quoting feature to quote article into reply
Go to Next message: Will Dunham: "Robot, Heal Thyself -- Welcome to the Future"
Go to Previous message: "Re: Camera Phones Focus on Police Misconduct on Los Angeles"
TELECOM Digest: Home Page