by David Lazarus
Nearly 10 billion text messages are sent by U.S. cell phone users
every month. If you don't think that's caught the attention of
spammers, think again.
One recent study indicates that millions of text-message spams are in
circulation already. The majority target younger cell phone users who
send the most text messages. But experts say it could be just a matter
of time before text spam becomes more widespread.
What's more, many cell phone subscribers face the double whammy of
having to pay 10 cents for every text message received, whether read
or unread, solicited or unsolicited.
"Spam is a growing concern in the wireless realm," acknowledged Heidi
Flato, a spokeswoman for Verizon Wireless. She said her company
filters up to 50,000 spam messages every day before they can reach
customers' cell phones.
Palo Alto resident Bill Zaumen is one of numerous wireless customers
to see a recent increase in the amount of spam arriving via his cell
phone. He told his service provider, Cingular, to block all text
messages, which it did.
But the experience got Zaumen thinking.
Why is it, he wondered, that protecting himself is an all-or-nothing
proposition? Why does he have to block all text messages, cutting off
any legitimate messages that may come his way?
Moreover, Zaumen wondered if the wireless companies aren't accomplices
to a crime. Since 2003, federal and state laws have prohibited the
sending of unwanted text messages.
"These companies are charging for an illegal activity," Zaumen
said. "They're profiting from it. Shouldn't they be more responsible
for upholding the law?"
William Baker, a Washington attorney and expert in telecom law, says
no.
He said unwanted text messages might be an annoyance, and a costly one
at that. But unless consumers are comfortable with having wireless
companies read each text message before it arrives, he doesn't see how
the carriers can be charged with abetting a crime.
"Legally, their job is to deliver messages," Baker observed. "They
deliver them. They've done their job."
However, consumer advocates say the situation isn't so cut-and-dried.
Cell-phone companies can do a lot more, they say, to ensure that
customers aren't paying through the nose for wireless spam.
"They haven't done very much to make it easier for people to block
messages from some sources but allow them from others," said Joe
Ridout, a spokesman for Consumer Action in San Francisco.
The reason, he said, is simple: Wireless companies make money from
every message sent and every message received.
"They have a profound disincentive to do anything about this problem,"
Ridout said. "That's why we've seen more foot-dragging than proactive
efforts to help customers."
According to CTIA, a wireless industry group, 48.7 billion text
messages were sent domestically in the second half of last year --
almost double the amount sent in the corresponding period a year
before.
CTIA says there are about 208 million wireless subscribers in the
United States, and they send roughly 10 billion text messages each
month.
The Pew Research Center found in a separate study last year that 28
percent of people who send text messages are receiving spam -- and
being charged in most cases for each unwanted message spilling into
their phones.
The Federal Communications Commission prohibits the sending of
unwanted "commercial messages" to cell-phone users. The loophole,
however, is that the rule doesn't apply to any company with which a
consumer has had a prior relationship.
California enacted a similar law in 2003.
"It's a serious enough problem that we're taking steps to make sure it
doesn't become more widespread," said Lauren Garner, a Cingular
spokeswoman. She declined to elaborate.
A common example of text-message spam occurs when people download new
ring tones to their cell phones. Often, the ring tones are accompanied
by a blizzard of text messages offering other services, which the
consumer might not notice until his or her next phone bill arrives.
Text messages can accompany other cell-phone transactions as well,
such as voting for "American Idol" contestants or playing wireless
games. One such game was promoted by Verizon recently as part of
marketing efforts for the movie "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's
Chest."
This is legal under federal law. What's illegal is when a marketing
company obtains the cell-phone numbers for thousands of customers of
any given provider and starts sending out pitches.
"We've been getting more and more complaints about this happening,"
said Ridout at Consumer Action.
Most wireless companies focus their filtering efforts on known
spammers. Customers are typically given the option of blocking
messages from specific senders.
This, of course, leaves the door open for other spammers to get
through -- at 10 cents a pop for cell-phone customers without costlier
plans that accommodate more text messages.
The more consumer-friendly approach would be for all text messages to
be blocked except for those from senders given a green light by
individual customers -- a "safe list" that could be regularly updated
online by the wireless customer.
That way, you're charged only for the messages you send and the ones
you want to receive. Everything else falls by the wayside.
Not one major wireless company gives customers this option, although
Cingular offers a service that blocks all text messages except those
sent to a separate address created by the subscriber.
Laura Marriott, executive director of the Mobile Marketing
Association, an industry group, said such a system is unnecessary
because of various safeguards already in place, such as spam filters
and guidelines for association members that consumers "opt in" before
receiving any text messages.
"We have done an extraordinary job as an industry to protect consumers
from spam," she said.
But Mark Cooper, research director for the Consumer Federation of
America, said the association's efforts won't prevent unscrupulous
marketers from obtaining consumers' cell-phone numbers and sending out
a torrent of spam.
"Relying on a code of conduct doesn't protect consumers," he said.
Cooper said a safe list of designated text senders would remedy the
situation. But he said this is unlikely as long as wireless companies
profit from every message that makes its way to customers' cell
phones.
"The problem is that the companies would have to administer the safe
list," he said. "They're not going to want to administer it."
After all, what's in it for them?
David Lazarus' column appears Wednesdays, Fridays and Sundays. Send
tips or feedback to dlazarus@sfchronicle.com.
URL: http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2006/08/04/MNGILKB9L51.DTL
Copyright 2006 San Francisco Chronicle
Path: telecom-digest.org!ptownson
Date: Mon, 30 Oct 2006 11:46:40 EST
From: telecomdirect_daily <telecomdirect_daily-owner@telecomdirectnews.com>
Newsgroups: comp.dcom.telecom
Subject: TelecomDirect News Daily Update - October 30, 2006
Reply-To: telecomdirect_daily-owner@telecomdirectnews.com
Message-ID: <telecom25.374.4@telecom-digest.org>
Organization: TELECOM Digest
Sender: editor@telecom-digest.org
X-URL: http://telecom-digest.org/
X-Submissions-To: editor@telecom-digest.org
X-Administrivia-To: telecom-request@telecom-digest.org
X-Telecom-Digest: Volume 25, Issue 374, Message 4 of 9
Lines: 80
********************************
PricewaterhouseCoopers Presents
The TelecomDirect News Daily Update
For October 30, 2006
********************************
Free-for-All from FON with Wi-Fi Router Giveaway
http://www.telecomdirectnews.com/do.php/140/20796?11228
Big-name-backed Spanish start-up FON launched a promotion in the
U.S. market last Friday as it gave away 'hundreds' of Wi-Fi
routers. The company has pushed into San Francisco as the touted
municipal Wi-Fi network to be provided by Google and EarthLink
has stalled. The next promotion is slated to hit New York as FON
tries to ...
EU Warns It Will Sue Germany If It Adopts Law Shielding Deutsche Telekom
http://www.telecomdirectnews.com/do.php/140/20791?11228
BRUSSELS, Belgium -- The European Union reiterated Monday that it
would take Germany to court if its parliament passes a law that
allows Deutsche Telekom AG to shut out rivals from its high-speed
broadband network. The former state monopoly wanted a three-year
exemption from rules that would prevent it recouping its initial
803 ...
Fiber Optics Reach for the Sky
http://www.telecomdirectnews.com/do.php/150/20787?11228
On an airplane, a little short circuit can lead to big trouble.
In 1996, a spark caused by faulty wiring insulation exploded
fumes inside TWA Flight 800's fuel tank, leading to a
horrific explosion and crash that killed 230 people. In an
effort to make aircraft safer, researchers have created an
optical on-off switch. The ...
Bang & Olufsen Teams with Samsung
http://www.telecomdirectnews.com/do.php/150/20785?11228
Attention, minimalists with disposable income: Bang and Olufsen
America, with help from Samsung Electronics Mobile Business, may
have the phone for you. Their partnership is bringing one of the
more unique phones to the North American market next month.
Marking the first cell phone to launch through Bang and Olufsen
America, ...
Sierra Wireless Turns It Around
http://www.telecomdirectnews.com/do.php/120/20782?11228
Sierra Wireless, buoyed by the growth of wireless data services
and the introduction of widgetry to use the new technologies --
which it supplies to both Cingular and Sprint, among others --
reported a strong third quarter, with sales nearly doubling and a
profit to boot. The company now has turned in four profitable
quarters in a ...
Talk Like an Egyptian
http://www.telecomdirectnews.com/do.php/110/20778?11228
As a small importer doing business with partners in the Middle
East, Steve Collins, owner of Discoveries, Inc. in Alexandria,
Va., has lived through the slow evolution of overseas
telecommunications in the last quarter-century. After founding
Discoveries in 1980, Collins first began working with his
Cairo-based affiliates by telex, ...
IP PBX Adoption Rate Dependent Upon New Services, Software
http://www.telecomdirectnews.com/do.php/150/20776?11228
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- With the move to IP, the PBX is no longer a
standalone system, but rather just one component of a larger
unified corporate communication system that includes e-mail,
IM/presence, dual-mode phones, video conferencing, etc., reports
In-Stat. Full IP PBX deployments across the entire scope of the
enterprise remain ...
TelecomDirect Editor <telecom_direct_editor@us.pwc.com>
Copyright (C) 2006 PricewaterhouseCoopers.
David Lazarus (cron@telecom-digest.org)