TELECOM Digest OnLine - Sorted: Microsoft EU Battle Over Large Daily Fine

Microsoft EU Battle Over Large Daily Fine

David Lawsky (
Wed, 15 Feb 2006 16:25:29 -0600

By David Lawsky

Microsoft Corp. formally denied European Commission charges that could
lead to 2 million euro ($2.4 million) daily fines in an antitrust case
on Wednesday, saying critical evidence had been ignored.

But the European Commission, in an unusual statement, said Microsoft
had filed the evidence 11 days after a deadline in December -- once
the Commission had already issued a Statement of Objections to fine
the company.

The Commission also said it is market testing Microsoft's plans to
offer access to source code, the blueprint for Microsoft's software.

The Commission had given the U.S. software giant until Wednesday to
explain why it should not be fined for failing to carry out sanctions
imposed in March 2004 for using its Windows software monopoly to
muscle out smaller competitors.

The company was supposed to provide rival makers of server software
with directions to allow their products to interconnect with Windows
desktop machines as easily as Microsoft's own server software, used
for work-group printer and other tasks.

The Commission said the directions were not workable but the company
disagreed in its formal response.


"Microsoft has complied fully with the technical documentation
requirements," it said in a nine-paragraph statement about its 75-page
confidential filing.

"The Commission has ignored critical evidence in its haste to attack
the company's compliance," Microsoft said.

Microsoft said that when the Commission issued the Statement of
Objections it and its experts "had not even bothered to read the most
recent version of those documents which Microsoft had made available
on 15 December 2005."

The Commission flatly rejected Microsoft's contention, saying
documents were available only at the company's headquarters in
Redmond, Wash.

Microsoft's obligation was to present the Commission in Brussels with
evidence that it had complied and that was not done until December 26,
the Commission said.

In any event, the Commission said the revised documentation was
essentially the same as the earlier, problematic version.

Microsoft also exercised its right to an oral hearing that must be
held before the Commission decides whether to impose the fine. The
Commission said that would be in the coming weeks.

The company said part of the problem was that the Commission
"repeatedly refused to clearly define its requirements and concerns,
despite repeated requests and accommodations by Microsoft."

One approach Microsoft took to deal with that was to offer to show its
source code to licensees.

The Commission said the source code license is being tested with
customers and evaluated by the monitoring trustee, chosen by the
Commission from several nominated by Microsoft.

Even before Microsoft put forward the idea, the trustee had no
enthusiasm for it, saying in the Statement of Objections: "I comment
that source code was never asked for nor indeed welcomed as a part of
an explanatory document."

The trustee also called Microsoft's documentation "fundamentally

Microsoft responded to that with two reports by professors it employed
and labeled as "independent experts," that it said show the
documentation met industry standards.

In addition, Microsoft said that much work had gone into the

"Hundreds of Microsoft employees and contractors have worked for more
than 30,000 hours to create over 12,000 pages of detailed technical
documents that are available for license today," the company said.

Copyright 2006 Reuters Limited.

NOTE: For more telecom/internet/networking/computer news from the
daily media, check out our feature 'Telecom Digest Extra' each day at . Hundreds of new
articles daily. And, discuss this and other topics in our forum at (or)

For more news and headlines from Reuters, please go to:

Post Followup Article Use your browser's quoting feature to quote article into reply
Go to Next message: BBC News Wire: "Microsoft Hits Back at EU Threats"
Go to Previous message: Joel Rothstein & Paul Eckert: "Congress Grills Internet Executives"
TELECOM Digest: Home Page