TELECOM Digest OnLine - Sorted: U.S. Enters Blackberry Patent Fight

U.S. Enters Blackberry Patent Fight

Stephanie Stoughton (
Fri, 11 Nov 2005 17:17:15 -0600


The U.S. government has inserted itself in a high-stakes patent fight
over the popular BlackBerry device, saying it wants to make sure
federal workers won't be cut off from mobile access to their e-mail.

The Justice Department filed a "statement of interest" earlier this
week to explain how the U.S. government, with as many as 200,000
BlackBerry users, could be harmed if a federal judge in Virginia
issues an injunction against Research In Motion Ltd. to stop selling
the device and accompanying e-mail service.

If the judge issues an injunction, "it is imperative that some
mechanism be incorporated that permits continuity of the federal
government's use of BlackBerry devices," the filing said.

The patent dispute with NTP Ltd. has heated with its return this week
to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia --
nicknamed the "Rocket Docket" for its speedy resolution of civil

And RIM may have more reason to be concerned. In a status hearing
Wednesday, Judge James R. Spencer appeared impatient to wrap up the
long-running suit brought by NTP, which convinced a jury in 2003 that
the technology behind the BlackBerry infringes on its patents.

The judge immediately dashed one of RIM's hopes. Spencer said it was
unlikely he'd delay proceedings to wait for a re-examination NTP's
patents by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, which recently issued
preliminary rulings questioning their validity.

"I don't run their business and they don't run mine," Spencer said,
asserting that he had spent enough time on the suit and intended to
move swiftly on key issues.

Spencer, who issued an injunction against RIM after the 2003 jury
verdict, but stayed it pending appeals, could rule before Thanksgiving
on whether a $450 million settlement deal reached earlier this year is

RIM says it is. NTP says it was never finalized.

The government filing by Paul J. McNulty, U.S. Attorney for the
Eastern District of Virginia, said "there does not appear to be a
simple manner in which RIM can identify which users of BlackBerries
are part of the federal government."

But James H. Wallace Jr., an NTP attorney, called McNulty's filing
"highly misleading and inappropriate."

Wallace said NTP has promised several times that an injunction would
not apply to any government or emergency personnel in the United
States, and said it would not be difficult for wireless carriers to
identify such users.

McNulty said one way to ensure continued e-mail service for government
employees would be to create a database of their devices. He suggested
the court delay consideration of the injunction for at least 90 days,
given the potential expense and complexity involved in inventorying
those BlackBerries.

The filing included an estimate that anywhere from 50,000 to 200,000
federal employees use BlackBerry devices, which allow employees to
retrieve and send e-mails when away from their office computers.

Copyright 2005 The Associated Press.

NOTE: For more telecom/internet/networking/computer news from the
daily media, check out our feature 'Telecom Digest Extra' each day at . Hundreds of new
articles daily.

For other Associated Press headlines and stories, please go to: (also)

Post Followup Article Use your browser's quoting feature to quote article into reply
Go to Next message: Patrick Townson: "If You Would Like to Get Away From ICANN Oversight and Registrars"
Go to Previous message: Ted Bridis: "Sony to Suspend Making Antipiracy CDs"
TELECOM Digest: Home Page